Category Archives: Essays

May 25, 2013

ESSAY

The President’s Speech

obama-ndu

President Obama has a strategy for American counterterror policy and he is sticking to it; that was the core message of the speech the President gave Thursday at the National Defense University.

Confronted by a troubling strategic and political situation in the world at large as well as in the complex conflict that he does not want to call a ‘global war on terror,’ the President offered a careful, thoughtful speech that doubled down on the core foreign policy themes he has sought to promote since accepting the Democratic presidential nomination in the summer of 2008.

The President is a man who believes that speeches matter; his critics sometimes accuse him of believing that making speeches and making policy are the same thing. He has no doubt learned in the White House that this is not always true; nevertheless, President Obama does not take major foreign policy addresses lightly. Like his speech in Cairo and his Nobel Prize acceptance speech in 2009, yesterday’s speech was intended as a comprehensive and definitive statement of the ideas by which he intends to be guided in the remaining years of his second term. Both supporters and critics of the President should study it carefully; it is the best available window into the mind of the man onto whose shoulders the responsibility for American security rests. Continue reading

Comments

May 22, 2013

ESSAY

Jobs Jobs Jobs

jobsjobsjobs

As the latest round of scandals swirls around the White House, there is the usual empty chatter from various spokesmen about the President’s intention to “pivot toward the economy” (again!) and to prioritize unemployment.

If only that would happen; America’s jobs problem is big enough and crucial enough that it should be the President’s priority every day, not something to pivot toward every now and then. Creating an environment conducive to job creation is make or break for our society, and there is much to be done to get things on the right track.

There are really two choices before us as we think about the future of jobs in an age of information. Either most human beings are about to become economically obsolete, or the information economy can find a use for their talent and hard work. Much depends on which of these two pictures turns out to be the best description of the future. Continue reading

Comments

May 16, 2013

ESSAY

The Jobs Question: Work Is A Human Right

ALine

Pretty much everybody understands at some level that the question of jobs is at the heart of America’s politics today. An old world of stable, reasonably well paid jobs in manufacturing (stuff processing) and in corporate or government bureaucracies (information processing) is passing away. What comes next is up in the air, but as things stand we see growing insecurity, inequality and a darker outlook for youth.

The argument about how to address the jobs question is the single political issue that has the most to do with how the country will develop for the next twenty years. Political disputes over hot button social policy issues like gay marriage or affirmative action often get more attention, but underneath the noise it is the question of jobs that will shape the way our institutions and policies develop. After all, creating the best possible conditions for large numbers of Americans to make good livings and achieve their personal goals engages the electorate’s attention year in and year out. Scandals and controversies come and go, even long wars come to an end sometime, but in times like ours when people aren’t sure that the economy will allow them to make a good living, the job question never really goes away. Continue reading

Comments

May 15, 2013

ESSAY

Gosnell: The Killer Had Help

kermit

After a full and fair trial, abortion doctor Kermit Gosnell was convicted this week on three counts of first-degree murder in the killing of three babies whose necks he “snipped,” as well as involuntary manslaughter in the death of patient Karnamaya Mongar. Gosnell, who performed hundreds of gruesome and macabre abortions out of his Women’s Medical Society Clinic, managed to skirt the death penalty when he agreed to forego an appeal in exchange for a life sentence. The sentencing brings to end a trial that revealed the gruesome practices of Gosnell and his staff. But more disturbing is the grotesque oversight and inaction of the bureaucrats who knew what was happening, and whose responsibility it was to protect the women and infants Gosnell murdered and maimed.

Gosnell spent nearly forty years running his clinic. According to the grand jury report, during that time he performed hundreds of abortions on women who were well past the legal gestational stage, inducing labor and snipping the spinal cord of babies that were born alive. The procedures were messy, frequently botched, and sent dozens of women to the emergency room with severe infections that left some near death. Anesthetics were frequently overused, which is what led to Karnamaya’s eventual overdose and death. The list of horrors goes on and on, but we’ll spare you the gory details. Continue reading

Comments

May 10, 2013

ESSAY

The Jobs Crisis: Bigger Than You Think

jobs

Of the Big Five questions facing America today, the most pressing and urgent is the question of jobs. This is more than the problem of recovering from the last economic slump; it is more than the impact of globalization and automation on manufacturing jobs. The American economy is shedding jobs, especially long-term, well-paying jobs with good benefits, and the jobs that replace them are often less secure and less well paid. The relentless transformation of the American labor market is changing the nature of American life, calling into question some of the basic assumptions and building blocks of the last fifty years, and generating a complex mix of political and social pressures that will shake the country to its foundations.

Essentially, the problem is this: automation and IT are moving routine processing, whether that being processed is information or matter, out of the realm of human work and into the realm of machines. Factory floors are increasingly automated places where fewer and fewer human beings are needed to transform raw materials into finished products; clerical work and many forms of mass employment in business, government and management are also increasingly performed more economically by computers than by trained human beings. Continue reading

Comments

May 5, 2013

ESSAY

The Big Five: America’s Make or Break Challenges

flag

So far, 2013 has been a bush league year in American politics. Gay marriage, gun control and amnesty for illegal immigrants are hot button emotional issues and they have a lot of practical importance for a lot of people, but the republic will not stand or fall based on lesbian prenups, gun background checks or green cards for those immigrants formerly known as illegal. Similarly with the sequester; if the country is headed toward fiscal bankruptcy the cuts are too small to save us and if the cuts are unnecessary they are neither large enough to precipitate a depression or so savage and stringent as to take us back to the social conditions of the 19th century.

So the headlines this year have not, exactly, been much ado about nothing, but it’s a lot of ado about nothing much. That wouldn’t matter if we didn’t have serious issues to deal with.  In quiet times we could let media cover politics the way the Weather Channel covers storms, inflating Winter Storms Chutney and Magpie into major world historical events. But we don’t live in bush league times. The United States has urgent business before it today and until and unless we get the big things fixed, we’re going to stagger from one ill-tempered squabble to another even as our underlying problems become more severe. Continue reading

Comments
ESSAY

Syria: Obama’s Own ‘Problem From Hell’

obama-assad

The Syrian civil war exploded over the weekend, with mass murder and sectarian cleansing along the coast, Israeli airstrikes in Damascus, and confusion, frustration and paralysis in Washington to the point where the New York Times described President Obama as trapped “in a geopolitical box, his credibility at stake with frustratingly few good options.”

Foreign policy, it turns out, is hard. Samantha Power, President Obama’s special advisor on the national security council, author of a very influential history of genocide (A Problem from Hell) that criticized the US failure to save Rwandans under President Clinton, and possible future US ambassador to the United Nations, announced earlier this year that she was leaving the administration to focus on her two young children. It’s an honorable and understandable decision, but it leads to a disturbing truth. Bashar Assad has outlasted Professor Power, and the country’s most influential advocate of the right to protect left office having failed to a make any headway against the greatest mass slaughter since the Rwandan genocide. Continue reading

Comments

April 24, 2013

ESSAY

The GOP and the Bush Legacy: Part Three

bush-top

My previous two essays on the GOP and President Bush touched off an interesting and mostly civil debate on the blogosphere, though if I’d known I was writing within a few days of the opening of the former Commander and Chief’s Presidential Library, I probably would have waited a week. Alas, even the finely tuned news detectors here at Via Meadia allow stories here and there to pass unnoticed; there was no intention to rain on anyone’s parade and if anyone took particular offense at the timing, I apologize. Discourtesy to presidents present or past is not the goal.

Timing aside, I’m glad that so many people have jumped into the discussion, but we need some clarity on what the debate should be. The conversation the Republican Party and the country need to have isn’t one about the past; it’s about the future. As I said before, it isn’t about whether Bush was, as a matter of fact, a good or bad President. This is something a lot of the responses to my original pieces have missed. Over at Foreign Policy, Will Inboden raised some representative questions about my pieces. Inboden’s main point is most clearly stated here (but read the whole thing) Continue reading

Comments

April 21, 2013

ESSAY

Gentry Liberals and Brass Knuckles: The Case of Maureen Dowd


If Maureen Dowd’s evisceration manqué of President Obama’s gun control strategy in the New York Times is any indication, Ms. Dowd is in the wrong line of work. She doesn’t understand American politics. She doesn’t know how votes are gained and lost, she doesn’t know what presidents do or understand what powers they have, and above all she doesn’t understand how politicians think. Continue reading

Comments

April 16, 2013

ESSAY

The GOP and the Bush Legacy: Part Two

BushSmall

It makes former Bush aide Peter Wehner really unhappy that anyone would criticize President W. Bush. In our latest essay, we noted that the Bush presidency remains widely unpopular and that national Bush fatigue remains a serious political problem for the Republican Party. We said that “more went right under Bush than most of his critics understood,” but counseled Republicans to spend less energy fighting what is pretty much a settled public judgment about the Bush administration and focus their attention on building for the future. We suggested that the GOP needs to talk about “lessons learned” and give the very large majority of Americans who consider the Bush administration a failure more reason to think that another Republican in the White House would mean something different.

Mr. Wehner’s response, entitled “Walter Russell Mead’s Shallow and Misleading Attack on the Bush Legacy,” is an impressive attempt to prove that everything popularly regarded as a Bush failure was in reality a great success. Insofar as any failure befell the White House, others were to blame. Indeed, reading Wehner’s response, it seems that Hurricane Katrina and the financial crash were both grossly unfair to a set of brilliant policies that deserved much better from an ungrateful world and that Heaven vouchsafed the American people a president whose many excellences they were incapable of appreciating in full. Continue reading

Comments

April 15, 2013

ESSAY

The Wreck of the Euro

shutterstock_90615325

What does it mean for the euro that, on paper at least, Spaniards, Italians, and Cypriots are much wealthier on average than Germans? That’s the question Wolfgang Münchau tackled in a must-read column in the Financial Times, and it’s one that VM readers would do well to spend some time thinking through.

Here are the outlines of his argument. A new survey by the European Central Bank has concluded that median German household wealth ranks among the lowest in the entire Eurozone. The median German family is worth €51,000 whereas the median Cypriot household is worth €267,000. Those are eye-popping figures, and the German press is apoplectic over them. Münchau cautions that the median is not the best measure in this case. But even if one were to look at the mean, Germans are worth €200,000 per household, while Spanish net wealth is somewhere around €300,000. There’s another correction to take on board; Germans haven’t bought into home ownership the way many Europeans (and Americans) do. But put in all the caveats and corrections you want, and the numbers are still striking and, to many Germans, infuriating. Why should German households be paying tax money to bail out rich Cypriots?

But anybody who’s traveled in Europe understands that these numbers have something wrong with them. Germans are significantly richer than Italians and Greeks. The answer, says Münchau, must be that varying price levels across the eurozone are responsible. Continue reading

Comments

April 11, 2013

ESSAY

The GOP Needs To Talk About Bush: Part One

George W. Bush

Many Republicans don’t like to admit this out loud, especially the power establishment that was close to the Bush administration or served in its upper echelons, but the Bush administration was a first class political disaster for the president’s party. Until Republicans find a way to talk about what went wrong and how future Republican administrations will do better, the GOP will face a stiff headwind of well-merited public distrust.

I don’t agree with the professional Bush-bashers and am perfectly willing to give the Bush administration its due. Not every decision the President made was bad, and the circumstances of his administration were difficult and harsh. President Bush was, is, a decent and honorable man who did his level best in the world’s most difficult job.  The Democrats who ran against him might have done considerably worse. Some of the things that went wrong were not his fault and more went right under Bush than most of his critics understood. Many of the failings of those years were due more to execution than to vision and to tone more than substance. It was also true, and brutally true at times, that the press corps did everything it could to shine the brightest possible spotlight on every pimple on the face of the Bush administration. There was no wart, no scar, no stretch mark on the Bush administration that didn’t get its full fifteen minutes of fame.

But make every allowance you can, discount the press bias and polish up the accomplishments as much as you like, and the conclusion still cannot be evaded: George W. Bush’s presidency was not a success and its result was to diminish the credibility of the ideas he professed and to damage the brand of the party whose standard he bore.
Continue reading

Comments

April 9, 2013

ESSAY

Maggie Thatcher Versus the Establishment

MaggieThatcherSmall

She was, beyond a doubt, the greatest British political leader since Winston Churchill and, like him, she was cordially hated by many grandees of the party she led.

The entire British establishment, from the royal family down, often wished she would just go away. In the end, a Cabinet cabal proved too much for her and drove her into exile.

Britain hates talent, at least in its rulers. Maggie Roberts wasn’t just talented – she was the incarnation of everything the 20th century British establishment loathed.

She was female, a trained scientist, aggressively middle class, personally assertive, openly nationalist, got on well with Jews and was utterly opposed to the mix of tepid socialism and stale one-nation Toryism that constituted the middle ground of British politics during the disastrous generation following World War Two. Continue reading

Comments

April 3, 2013

ESSAY

AP: Obama an Appeaser on Iran?

obama-assad

One of the ongoing perplexities of President Obama’s Syria policy has been the stark contrast between his muscular rhetoric and halting, hesitant actions. On the one hand, he has insisted that the country’s dictator Bashar al-Assad “must” go and has predicted that his fall is all but assured. But on the other, he has thus far limited himself to authorizing aid in the form of training and intelligence for Syria’s beleaguered rebels.

While we’d be the last to conclude that the case for intervening in Syria is open and shut, we have argued here at Via Meadia that the case for action outweighs the case for doing nothing. Barely. We’ve been making the case that the consequences of inaction were too high for quite a while now, and with every passing week, as the situation on the ground becomes increasingly dire and pushes the more reasonable among the rebels to the sidelines, we are convinced that our initial assessment was the right one, and that the choices available to President Obama and the West generally grow less attractive with each passing day. Continue reading

Comments

March 26, 2013

ESSAY

Gay Marriage: From Sexual Outlaws to Sexual In-Laws

In case you hadn’t heard, the Supreme Court this week is entertaining two gay marriage cases. On Tuesday, the Justices heard oral arguments about Proposition 8, the California ballot proposition that mandated that only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California. On Wednesday they hear arguments about the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), a federal law that defines marriage as between one man and one woman for federal purposes. The decisions on the cases won’t be handed down until June, but virtually the entire commentariat has been jumping in. On homosexuality as well as on marriage, everyone is an expert.

We’re no exceptions here at Via Meadia. WRM’s Twitter profile states our corporate motto. “Opinions are like love; the more you give away, the more you have.” And like everybody else in the United States, we have opinions about gay marriage.

But before getting into the marriage question, there’s one thing that needs to be said very clearly. You can be for gay marriage or you can be against it, but the hating and the bullying must end. The climate of bigotry, brutality and violence that so many gay people have had to live with in the past was clearly an evil. It’s a terrible thing when teenagers are driven to suicide by fears that their own families will reject them over homosexuality. Gay bashing and discrimination have no place in a civilized polity. The emerging American consensus to put all this behind us is a step into the light. Those who want to attack gay marriage and complain about the destruction of traditional morality need to reflect on how evil the old ways sometimes were and remember that some traditions need to be smashed. Continue reading

Comments